Target 8 Fact Check: Analyzing Prop A ad claims

2 months 2 weeks 4 days ago Thursday, August 02 2018 Aug 2, 2018 Thursday, August 02, 2018 8:55:00 PM CDT August 02, 2018 in Target 8
By: Hannah Thomas, KOMU 8 Reporter
loading

COLUMBIA - Proposition A is a hotly contested initiative that is seeing controversial claims on both sides.  On August 7, Missouri voters will decide if Missouri will become a "right to work" state.

Supporters say right to work will draw business to the state and give workers the choice not to pay into a union. Opponents say it's an attempt to weaken unions and could lead to lower wages.

Twenty-seven states in the country are right to work states.

Rabindra Bhandari, a professor of economics at Westminster College, said, right now, ads for and against Prop A are heavily partisan.

"The ads released for right to work are more politically-based. They're not necessarily about how this would benefit the states," he said.

Bhandari said there are two main arguments when it comes to Prop A. First is the issue of individual freedoms, people being able to choose if they want to join labor unions or not. Second is the matter of economics and making the state more competitive.

“People who oppose Prop A, oppose it because it allows a certain group of people to free-ride on the dues are paid by somebody else.”

Bhandari called this “the tragedy of the commons,” a situation where some individuals gain short-term benefits at the expense of the majority.

He also said, while unions will still exist in right to work states, they will not have the same negotiating power.

KOMU 8 News fact-checked claims made in ads by We Are Missouri, an organization against Prop A and National Right to Work, an organization for Prop A.

This video, by National Right to Work, supports Proposition A.

Claim: Prop A outlaws forced political contributions and dues.

In response to this, We Are Missouri spokesman Jack Cardetti says union dues, by law, are not allowed to go to political campaigns or candidates.

"All political contributions [from unions] are voluntary funds.They're kept in a completely separate fund and can only be done voluntarily," he said. 

The Federal Election Commission states campaigns may not accept contributions from labor organizations, the treasury funds of corporations or national banks. However, labor unions are allowed to pay administrative or operating costs of Political Action Committees or PACs.

Result: We find this claim false.

Labor unions cannot force their workers to contribute to political campaigns.

Claim: "...[unions] have funneled 1.1 billion dollars in forced worker dues to liberal causes and candidates.

National Right to Work was not available for an interview but responded in a statement, saying that number is now updated to $1.3 billion. The cited number comes from a website backed by union opponents. 

Some of the "liberal causes" named in the ad by National Right to Work are "pro-abortion, anti-second amendment and open borders." The "liberal candidates" named in the ad are former presidential candidate Hillary Clinton and Minority Leader of the U.S. House of Representatives Nancy Pelosi.

 Result: We find this claim incomplete.

The Center for Responsive Politics, a non-profit, nonpartisan research group that tracks the effects of money and lobbying on elections and public policy, says none of the top donors of Pelosi or Clinton's campaigns are labor unions.

In fact, PAC contributions to Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign accounted for only 0.31 percent of all donated funds.

In Pelosi's case, 27.39 percent of donated funds came from PACs.

Claim: State economies, jobs and worker buying power are all growing faster in freedom to work states.

Buying power is the money an investor has available to buy securities and equals the total cash held in the brokerage account plus all available margin. National Right to Work cited the National Institute for Labor Relations Research (NILRR), which is a research institute funded by National Right to Work, according to the progressive Center for Media and Democracy, a nonprofit watchdog group.

NILRR said it finds that real purchasing power is higher in right to work states. National Right to Work claims its calculations used statistics from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. According to the NILRR fact sheet, right to work states have also seen higher economic growth. 

Result: We find this claim incomplete.

KOMU 8 News found this claim incomplete because of NILRR's affiliation with National Right to Work. 

This video, by We Are Missouri, opposes Proposition A

Claim: Wages go down in right to work states. Families make $8,740 less per year. 

Cardetti said We are Missouri used data from the 2016 US Census Bureau.

"If you add up the 27 right to work states and the other states that don't have right to work, including Missouri, and you look at median household income, it's really important to look at what the middle class is making," he said.

Result: We find this claim false

In right-to-work states like Kansas, the average median income is $2,000 less than Missouri, while in Iowa, the average median income is higher than Missouri.

Compared to right to work states like Alabama and Florida, Missouri makes more in average median income.

Claim: CEOs still make 361 times more than the average worker.

"All CEOs in Fortune 500 companies and publicly trade companies have to produce that type of information on their annual SEC filings. So that number comes straight out of their SEC filings," Cardetti said.

Result: We find this claim unconfirmed.

After lengthy research, KOMU 8 News could not see any evidence confirming nor denying the number associated with the claim.

Further arguments from both sides

In a statement, Patrick Semmens, spokesman for the National Right to Work Committee, said the following about the anti-Right to Work ads:

“It’s unfortunate that union bosses won’t level with the people of Missouri about Right to Work’s real impact. It’s shameful that union bosses are spending so much money, much of it from forced dues, just to protect their power to have a worker fired simply for refusing to hand over part of their pay check to union officials.“

In response to the Vote Yes on Prop A ads, Cardetti said "What Prop A really is, is it’s a race to the bottom. We think it's very disingenuous that this Virginia-based special interest committee to make those type of claims. What they ought to be looking at is what the middle-class makes in right to work states compared to Missouri. That's the true apples to apples comparison."

More News

Grid
List
HERMANN - One person was killed in a crash involving a trolley, the Missouri State Highway Patrol said. Sgt.... More >>
5 hours ago Saturday, October 20 2018 Oct 20, 2018 Saturday, October 20, 2018 6:16:00 PM CDT October 20, 2018 in News
(CNN) -- President Donald Trump announced Saturday that the US is pulling out of the landmark Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty... More >>
6 hours ago Saturday, October 20 2018 Oct 20, 2018 Saturday, October 20, 2018 5:11:00 PM CDT October 20, 2018 in News
COLUMBIA – Nineteen members of Missouri Task Force One returned to Boone County Fire Protection District headquarters Saturday morning after... More >>
8 hours ago Saturday, October 20 2018 Oct 20, 2018 Saturday, October 20, 2018 3:16:00 PM CDT October 20, 2018 in News
SPRINGFIELD (AP) — A man has been criminally charged days after a woman's body was found near Fellows Lake at... More >>
9 hours ago Saturday, October 20 2018 Oct 20, 2018 Saturday, October 20, 2018 1:58:08 PM CDT October 20, 2018 in News
SPRINGFIELD (AP) — A Springfield woman who killed her live-in boyfriend with a crowbar in 2017 has been sentenced to... More >>
9 hours ago Saturday, October 20 2018 Oct 20, 2018 Saturday, October 20, 2018 1:48:36 PM CDT October 20, 2018 in News
ST. LOUIS (AP) — A restored St. Louis prairie of native grasses and flowers is in bloom, but the nature... More >>
14 hours ago Saturday, October 20 2018 Oct 20, 2018 Saturday, October 20, 2018 8:50:24 AM CDT October 20, 2018 in News
COLUMBIA - Sen. Claire McCaskill spoke about health care in Columbia on Friday at Laborers Local 955, as part of... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 7:35:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
COLUMBIA - After realizing the underrepresentation of Hispanic business owners in mid-Missouri, three Hispanic professionals established a group of 12... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 5:49:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
COLUMBIA - This is the last week of the regular season and it's a cold one. Our game of... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 5:20:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in Friday Night Fever
COLUMBIA - Two Midwest companies issued separate food recalls this week for bacterial contamination concerns. Hy-Vee said its supplier,... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 4:53:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
CAMDEN (AP) — Toxicology tests show that a boater was drunk when he slammed into a bluff at Missouri's Lake... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 3:41:35 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
COLUMBIA - The Legion of Black Collegians and the FourFront Marginalized Student Council held a solidarity walk Friday to show... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 3:39:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - The Missouri State Medical Association (MSMA), along with multiple medical associations, reaffirmed their opposition to the three... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 2:50:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - For the fourth consecutive year, Project Homeless Connect provided services Friday for people who are experiencing homelessness... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 2:39:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — The Mega Millions jackpot has soared to an estimated $1 billion, as the second-largest lottery... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 12:10:00 PM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - Police want the public's help finding a man who allegedly ran from a traffic stop after hurting... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 11:42:00 AM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
COLUMBIA - Two MU residence halls and an atrium were officially dedicated on Friday honoring three former MU students. Lucile... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 10:09:00 AM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
WASHINGTON (AP) — Just 1 in 4 people thinks Brett Kavanaugh was completely honest when as a Supreme Court nominee... More >>
1 day ago Friday, October 19 2018 Oct 19, 2018 Friday, October 19, 2018 9:58:13 AM CDT October 19, 2018 in News
Columbia, MO
Broken Clouds 39°
12am 39°
1am 37°
2am 36°
3am 35°